Shelter Island

Listings

Shelter Island has 19 active listings and the average listing price is $2,937,000. The typical home in Shelter Island has 4.3 beds, 4.1 baths, and is 3,322.6 SqFt. Land-only listings are excluded to provide accurate averages for price, size, beds, and baths

RECENT LISTINGS

IMAGE
ADDRESS
SOLD DATE
PROPERTY TYPE
CONFIGURATION
SOLD PRICE
26 S Menantic RD,  Shelter Island,  NY 11964
1
Single Family Home
4 beds
4 baths
1,702 SqFt
$1,460,000
$10K
73 N Midway RD,  Shelter Island,  NY 11964
1
Single Family Home
4 beds
3 baths
2,296 SqFt
$1,600,000
$245K
Unlock Recent Listings